On one aspect you’ve got the previous home lovers who will let you know, with full confidence, that previous homes are constructed higher than any new home in the present day. And on the opposite aspect you’ve got the brand new home individuals who suppose shopping for an previous home is the peak of madness as a result of identical to Tom Hanks and Shelley Lengthy you’re simply asking for a pockets draining, marriage killing, cash pit to throw your financial savings into. Who’s proper?
On this submit, I’ll attempt to format the info on either side to settle the argument (hopefully) as soon as and for all. Learn on and inform me if I’ve satisfied you of something or now you’re simply dug in in your aspect much more than earlier than.
Professionals of Previous Homes
There are some good explanation why previous homes deserve the title. Right here’s three causes I consider previous homes are constructed higher, however I’m positive you possibly can add extra.
Higher Supplies
With just a bit little bit of analysis it’s simple to find that previous homes had been constructed with supplies that we merely don’t have entry to in the present day. Issues like old-growth wooden which could be 2-3 occasions are stronger, extra steady, and extra rot-resistant than the lumber utilized in new homes in the present day mixed with conventional lime plaster that’s stronger, supplies higher sound and power insulation, and pulls CO2 from the air, and the previous homes of us can giggle all the way in which to financial institution figuring out that their properties are made from stuff new householders can solely dream of affording.
Time Examined
House development has modified quite a bit over the past century. Many elderly homes that had been constructed poorly have failed or been torn down so we’re left with a little bit of survivor bias with regards to previous homes. Solely the strongest have survived.
Which means when you have a really previous home the probabilities are wonderful that you’ve got probably the greatest previous homes. It has stood the take a look at of time and confirmed its resilience for the many years or centuries, and so there stands a superb opportunity it is going to proceed to take action for hundreds of years longer.
Distinctive
In an age the place there weren’t main publicly traded firms constructing properties, however reasonably an area military of particular person builders, the properties constructed previous to WWII had been way more distinctive and diverse than properties in the present day.
Neighborhoods had been deliberate, however the builders in these neighborhoods had been so diverse that they left a neighborhood with only a few comparable homes normally. That selection means every previous home is way extra distinctive than any new home, apart from maybe the customized excessive finish properties solely the ultra-wealthy can afford.
Cons of Previous Homes
Dwelling in an previous home shouldn’t be all the time rainbows and butterflies. They’ve their points and earlier than we transfer on to new homes we have now to deal with a few of these points right here.
Typically Uncared for
This one will get thrown round quite a bit and it is sensible. When you have an previous home that has been throughly “remuddled” it might probably depart a nasty impression, however abuse doesn’t rule out correct use.
Is it actually the fault of an previous home that’s has been abused and uncared for by earlier house owners? Wouldn’t the identical be true for a brand new home in 40-50 years. So, I believe we will examine this one off the listing.
Outdated Applied sciences & Supplies
Whereas previous homes do have premium constructing supplies like I discussed earlier not all the things is superb and plenty of of those are outdated. Issues like fabric wiring and knob & tube wiring could be harmful. Lead paint and asbestos are additionally not on my Christmas listing, however are a actuality in virtually any home constructed earlier than 1978.
I believe it’s truthful to say that this stuff, whereas they arrive in various portions, are a giant downside of previous homes. In fact, you possibly can have virtually all of these things resolved by renovations when you care to.
Too Many Unknowns
If your own home was constructed earlier than there was an area constructing code in your city then there’s a good probability the builder simply did no matter he needed to. The homes constructed by dangerous builders seemingly fell down or rotted away, however the good builders (or the fortunate ones) left us homes which have stood the take a look at of time.
However what’s inside these partitions? God solely is aware of. What’s the load score for that roof? No thought. Is the wiring as much as code in every single place? Ummmm. Whereas these previous homes have lasted for a very long time there are a variety of unknowns that may bust a funds with regards to previous homes and that deserves accounting for.
Professionals of New Homes
New homes definitely have their share of advantages that may’t go unaccounted for. So, let’s dive in and see the place issues shake out.
Vitality Effectivity
Sure, new homes are constructed to a lot stricter power requirements than previous homes. There’s a main deal with indoor air high quality, U-factors, SHGC, and wealth of different measures which were examined and adopted because the Nineteen Seventies. So, new homes get the benefit right here. Nicely performed new homes, properly performed.
Present Applied sciences
It’s not simply power effciency that wins on new homes but in addition the applied sciences that make the homes safer for its occupants. No extra lead paint or asbestos. Grounded wiring with much less probability of burning your own home down or electrocuting you. Air flow methods which might be only a tad higher than merely opening a window. Attic insulation that isn’t corn cobs? Yum!
New homes might not win on constructing supplies however for applied sciences this can be a clear win. However once more, a variety of these applied sciences that come normal with a brand new home could be retrofit onto previous homes with out an excessive amount of drama.
Structure
Previous homes had been constructed with a particular format in thoughts that labored for the individuals who initially lived in them. There have been dived into rooms with particular functions just like the parlor or lounge.
Right now, society craves an open flooring plan the place the kitchen and residing areas are all one area. Folks within the Twenties would have had a conniption match if visitors noticed their kitchen, in the present day we anticipate to hang around there. This one is a win for brand spanking new homes when you like an open flooring plan, however really a unfavorable when you just like the previous floorplan so this might go both method relying on the particular person.
Cons of New Homes
Poor Supplies
Working a cellular wooden rot enterprise I can let you know that I do way more wooden rot restore on properties constructed after 1970 than on properties constructed earlier than that point. Whereas supplies have improved within the final 20 years it’s extensively agreed that the worst interval for dwelling constructing by way of lowest high quality of constructing supplies was from the Nineteen Fifties by the Nineteen Eighties.
Many new properties have main failures in only a few years due to poor workmanship and poor supplies. As an alternative of constructing a home for generations like with previous homes, new homes are constructed as starter properties that ought to final simply nice for a pair many years earlier than they begin carrying out.
Cookie Cutter Design
Suburban sprawl is an actual factor and whenever you see neighborhoods with lots of of properties and solely 4-6 totally different designs the monotony is nearly insufferable.
When an business modifications from customized constructing to meeting line type manufacturing you’re assured to free the distinctiveness it as soon as had and that has clearly occurred with new properties and neighborhoods in the present day.
Lack of Repairability
You possibly can repair virtually something on an previous home, however on a brand new home? Not often can one thing be repaired. Home windows fog and must be changed. Vinyl siding breaks (or melts!) and wishes alternative. Within the alternative era you’ve got merely misplaced the flexibility to restore issues your self even when you needed to and that’s main price subject for house owners of latest homes versus previous householders who’ve the choice to restore.
The Ultimate Consequence
So, who wins? Are previous homes constructed higher? There isn’t a exact rating right here, however I can provide you my ideas and you may argue with me within the feedback if you wish to. I believe the previous homes take it.
They’ve confirmed their supremacy over many years or centuries and most of their points could be resolved with a renovation by a caring home-owner. Their repairability and uniqueness can’t be understated as a result of these are baked into the cake and no new home can win that argument. So do you agree or disagree?
Subscribe Now For Your FREE eBook!
Founder & Editor-in-Chief
I like previous homes, working with my arms, and educating others the excitment of doing it your self! All the things is teachable when you solely give it the prospect.